Armed robbery near downtown Manhattan Beach stirs furor
By Mark McDermott
A man and a woman were robbed at gunpoint Friday night, Oct. 9, near downtown Manhattan Beach, and the man was physically assaulted by one of the two suspects, who fled the scene and have not yet been identified or arrested.
The call came in at 8:11 p.m. The couple was on Manhattan Avenue near Sixth Street when two men confronted them, MBPD Chief Rachel Johnson said.
“One brandished a handgun and used that to strike one of the victims on the head, and took property and fled southbound out of the city,” Johnson said.
The man suffered a cut on his head. Johnson described what was taken only as “personal property.” Police had what she called “a very vague description” of the suspects and of “kind of a nondescript car.”
Accounts of the robbery began circulating on social media Sunday morning, Oct. 11.
The anonymous administrator of a Facebook group, Manhattan Beach Residents’ Forum Unfiltered, posted that “a prominent Manhattan Beach resident” had been mugged at gunpoint on Manhattan Avenue “between Fête Restaurant and Slay Italian Kitchen,” a block north of where police say it occurred.
On Monday, Oct. 12, the email newsletter MB Weekly reported that “two attackers armed with a gun mugged a man on Manhattan Ave. near Slay Italian Kitchen.” The item carried a call from former Mayor Mark Burton, a candidate in the Nov. 3 City Council election, for Johnson’s resignation. “Enough is enough,” Burton said, according to MB Weekly. He also called for regular foot patrols in the downtown commercial district.
Paul Wafer, an MB Weekly contributor, shared the item on the Facebook forum, where he wrote he has known Burton for almost 60 years and considers him “the best alternative to the entrenched politicians currently or recently on council.”
Richard Montgomery, a former mayor who is also running for council, posted on Instagram that “city sources” had said the department lacks the staffing for a dedicated foot patrol. He called on the council to direct the city manager to “immediately contact neighboring cities to explore hiring other officers temporarily until our staffing levels increase.”
“I will not be silent or stop pushing until I see uniformed MBPD officers walking downtown!” Montgomery wrote.
A column by retired MBPD Captain Tim Hageman in the same MB Weekly newsletter placed the robbery “south of downtown,” which matches the police account.
Kelly Stroman, executive director of the Downtown Manhattan Beach Business and Professional Association, addressed the conflicting accounts in an email update.
“The MBPD response to the victims was south of DTMB (between 5th and 6th), not in the immediate business district or ‘between two restaurants’, or ‘near’ Slay Italian on Man. Ave.,” Stroman wrote. “This has been repeatedly and incorrectly stated in social media and email marketing.”
“Don’t fall for the gossip, rumors and hate speech that is running rampant.”
Bob Beverly, owner of the Shellback Tavern, sharply disagreed in a reply copied to the City Council. “A Nixle alert should have been issued right away,” Beverly wrote. “A gun was involved and the suspects were and are on the loose.”
Johnson said the department uses Nixle alerts when residents can act on the information. That might mean avoiding an area, or watching for a suspect who matches a description.
“In this instance, there was nothing for the community to take action on,” she said. Police believed the suspects had left the city, and the description was too vague to help.
Hageman, who served nine years as an MBPD captain, argued in his column that the department should issue press releases for critical incidents. He wrote that its first social media notice came about 44 hours after the robbery.
For a robbery like this one, Johnson said, the department notifies its command staff, the city manager and the City Council under a protocol it presented to the council a couple of years ago, “and that’s typically where these notifications stop.” Press releases go out, she said, when “we think there’s an ongoing threat to the public, we think these suspects are still at large, and we think there’s a likelihood that they’re going to continue what they’re doing.”
“When we don’t have that information, we don’t send out a press release,” Johnson said.
That weekend, the department issued two press releases regarding a fatal collision and another, one-paragraph release regarding the robbery.
Johnson said the department reports crime through its weekly and monthly summaries, which are posted on social media and the city website, sent to subscribers and distributed to Neighborhood Watch.
“We believe transparency is an important part of maintaining public trust,” Johnson said. “While not every incident warrants the same level of notification, our goal is to provide the community with a consistent and comprehensive picture of crime and public safety in Manhattan Beach.”
Hageman also wrote that only 56 of the department’s 64 sworn officers are available for deployment, with eight away because of injuries or administrative leave. Johnson said those numbers are not accurate.
“There are fewer people who are out of the workplace,” she said. She declined to give figures, because some leaves are medically protected.
Johnson said officers already patrol downtown on foot. “It’s not a staffing issue by any stretch of the imagination,” she said. Supervisors routinely tell officers to get out of their cars, walk downtown and the pier, and make repeated passes through the business district. “They are highly visible,” Johnson said.
Yet even an officer on foot is not always seen, she said.
“If you pass by my office right now, I wouldn’t know that you were here, because I’m in my office. I’m not looking out my window,” Johnson said. “It doesn’t mean that you didn’t come by, right? It just means that I didn’t see you come by. Our officers are downtown.”
“We’re always talking in my staff meetings with my supervisors and my managers about being visible, being on foot downtown, being on foot at the pier, and being a visible deterrent to crime,” she said. “But that doesn’t mean that we can be everywhere at once, or that a criminal would say, ‘Oh, a police car just came by. I won’t commit any crimes.’”
“In our community, we’re all thinking like rational people,” Johnson said. “Criminals see opportunities where you and I would say, ‘Oh, the cops are really around here.’ Criminals are like, ‘Well, they just left. We have some time here.’ And so they see opportunities where you and I wouldn’t see things that way.”
The outcry over the robbery harkens back to the community response to two smash-and-grab robberies of Pasha Fine Jewelry on Manhattan Beach Boulevard in June 2022 and March 2023. In both, crews of men wielding hammers, several carrying what appeared to be handguns, shattered display cases in the heart of downtown. Arrests were made in both cases, but not immediately after the incidents. Five adults were sentenced to prison for the 2023 robbery. Four men were charged last year in the 2022 robbery.
Johnson drew a sharp line between the Oct. 9 robbery and the Pasha incidents.
“Let’s draw a distinction between a gaggle of armed suspects smashing cabinets at Pasha and robbing several people,” Johnson said. “And you’ll note we did a lot of community notification after that because of the nature of the crime. This is very much separate and apart from that, a very different scenario.”
The City Council authorized seven new sworn positions in early 2023, after the first Pasha robbery, raising the department’s authorized strength from 65 officers to 72. The council had first asked Johnson to explore armed private security downtown and contracts with outside agencies. When neither proved workable, it funded the new positions instead. The outside-agency approach is the one Montgomery urged after the robbery.
Filling police positions takes time. Candidates must pass written and physical tests, an extensive background check and an interview before six months in the academy and a subsequent field training program. The department now has eight recruits in the academy, Johnson said, more than it has ever had at one time.
Even if all eight graduate, she said, the department will keep hiring. “We know that we have folks who may retire, and we also know that not everyone’s going to make it through that entire process,” Johnson said. “But we have worked really hard to bring us very, very close to full staffing at the police department.”
Johnson said she understood the concern over the Oct. 9 robbery. Robberies of individuals are not rare in the city, she said, but most do not involve a gun. “We average about one robbery of this kind every month or so, not necessarily with a handgun,” Johnson said. More often, she said, someone looks threatening and demands money or a cell phone. “It doesn’t mean our city is unsafe. It means that, just like everywhere else, it’s very difficult to be free from crime.”
According to the department’s crime data, MBPD recorded 13 robberies in 2025, down from 16 in 2024 and 36 in 2023. Aggravated assaults fell by half over the same period, from 40 to 20.
With a population of about 35,000, Manhattan Beach’s 2025 robbery rate was less than half the statewide rate of 94.4 per 100,000 residents, according to the California Department of Justice. The statewide rate itself fell nearly 20 percent last year.
Anyone with information about the robbery, or with security camera footage from the area around 8 p.m. Oct. 9, is asked to contact the MBPD Detective Bureau at (310) 802-5120.
MBPD will hold a town hall Wednesday, Oct. 21, at 6 p.m. at the Joslyn Community Center. ER
A correction: The print edition of this story incorrectly identified Paul Wafer as publisher of MB Weekly. He is a contributor, not publisher. We regret the error.
Read this story on easyreadernews.com