The end of Big Mike’s marks end of a (cheesesteak) era
By Mark McDermott
The paper sign taped inside the glass door on 190th Street read, “Big Mike’s is permanently closed….We are deeply grateful for your support and letting us serve this community. Thank you.”
Big Mike’s Philly Steaks & Subs is gone. The Redondo Beach shop and its sister on Main Street in El Segundo both closed in late October. The sign gave no reason.
Big Mike’s Philly Steaks & Subs at 2431 W. 190th St. in Redondo Beach, which closed in October along with the El Segundo shop on Main Street.
“No word of why, or what will come to either location next,” Easy Reader dining writer Richard Foss wrote in his A La Carte column Nov. 5.
The El Segundo shop had been a Main Street landmark for 20 years. The Redondo shop opened in 2012.
Big Mike’s began at 1314 Hermosa Ave. in 1995. It was a few tables, a register and a counter facing the grill. Foss named it the South Bay’s best Philly cheesesteak in Easy Reader’s 2011 Best of the Beach and told diners to take the counter and watch.
“There’s some kind of East Coast magic going on here,” he wrote.
By 2015 Mike Neimark had three shops and a menu that roamed the East Coast. Hot dogs came Jersey style, with the fries inside the bun. Pittsburgh sandwiches came with coleslaw and fries. The crew had opinions about cheesesteaks.
“You’ll get an earful about why most places make them wrong,” Foss wrote that year.
The Hermosa original later changed hands and became the Hermosa Pub. Locals kept calling it Big Mike’s. In 2018, Foss reported, “the Philly cheesesteaks are still coming off the grill.” That shop has since closed.
El Segundo and Redondo carried on. A six-inch cheesesteak that ran about $5 in 2009 gave way to a $10.30 cheesesteak on this fall’s online menu.
“I’m seriously disappointed to see you suddenly close the Redondo location,” a Yelp reviewer who said he had been a customer since 1998 wrote Oct. 29. He added, “Open a new location please!”
“The late, great Big Mike’s. El Segundo’s loss,” another wrote Nov. 11. “This place fed a generation of surfers, soldiers, refinery workers, and students.”
Transplants took it hard.
“Big Mike’s may be the best Philly cheesesteak in LA,” an El Segundo customer wrote in a delivery review. “I haven’t had that Philly taste since I left PA.”
Photos of the sign went up on Facebook Oct. 30. Two posts drew nearly 100 comments between them.
“RIP Big Mikes Rb and El Segundo,” Brady Blaco wrote in a post tagged at the Redondo shop. “I remember when they first opened up on Hermosa Ave.”
Mention of the Hermosa shop evoked a lot of memories.
“On Hermosa Ave, my roommate got caught drunk stealing a block of cheese,” Korye Cybulski Finn wrote. “She had to flash her boobies to leave the kitchen. Oh, the Good Ol’ Days.”
“Lots of early morning cheesesteak after Sangria closed for the night,” Russell Schramm wrote.
“Good sandwiches, good times on Hermosa Avenue for sure,” Anthony Bergeron wrote. “They had a good run.”
Neimark sold the Hermosa shop years ago.
“Big Mike himself sold that spot years back,” Tim Doiron wrote. “He got out while still ahead thankfully.”
On a second post of the sign that day, commenters mourned the onion rings and garlic fries.
No new tenant has been announced for the Redondo space.
The Main Street space is not dark. Spread, Please!, a smash-burger shop that began as a nighttime pop-up inside the El Segundo Big Mike’s, still serves there from 4 to 10 p.m., seven days a week. Its owners describe themselves as “a crew of 20-year-old entrepreneurs.” Its Instagram profile says, “We fry in beef tallow!”
Read this story on easyreadernews.com