HB Council candidates divided over mixed use, beach ownership
By Laura Garber
by Laura Garber
Councilmember Rob Saemann wants mixed-use residential allowed in Hermosa Beach’s Arts District. School board member Maggie Bove-LaMonica wants it protected. The other four City Council candidates at the Monday, October 19, Leadership Hermosa debate were open to mixed-use housing on Cypress Avenue with conditions.
Moderators Ashkun Zaker, treasurer of Leadership Hermosa Beach, and Paul Reiner, the community outreach coordinator, asked at the third and final debate whether the candidates would allow residential zoning in the district, also known as the M1 area.
The Leadership Hermosa format allowed for rebuttals. Most of the rebuttals were focused on short-term rentals and the city budget.
“The Cypress district, I think absolutely we should put housing there,” Saemann said. “I think there should be an art district in Hermosa Beach, but a small one and the rest of that area should be open for housing.”
He said a “very small area” there has art spaces worth protecting.
“I am not in favor of turning our Arts District into high rise housing,” Bove-LaMonica said. “We have something incredibly special happening with the row of art galleries that’s happening down in Cypress right now, and I want to do everything possible to protect that.”
She said new housing belongs along busy corridors and warned of strain on sewers and roads. Bove-LaMonica noted that Saemann’s time on the Planning Commission “led to the city housing element, which was rejected by the state outright.”
Candidate Eric Horne said mixed use, if done properly, in the district “could add to the community” and the city needs new sites.
“We have not done a proper auditing our housing element overlay zone sites and it has put us in legal jeopardy,” Horne said.
He said the Trader Joe’s site counts for 40 low-income units in the city’s housing plan. “Any developer can look at that and say, that’s not a serious housing site,” he said.
Parks and Recreation Commissioner Elka Worner described the district as “surfboard shapers, galleries and offices.”
“I believe if it’s done tastefully, we could do mixed use housing and have a top floor for a studio or one bedroom and maintain the lower floors for whatever the businesses are,” Worner said.
She said she would rather see new housing on Pacific Coast Highway and Aviation Boulevard.
“Of course, housing should be allowed in a mixed use development, and we should encourage it,” Councilmember Dean Francois said. He said the city’s mixed use plan in the downtown, known as land value recapture, is a barrier to development.
“Certainly housing and art can work together. It’s a wonderful little art district we have,” Francois said.
“I support smart infill housing that fits Hermosa Beach and preserves our community character. There may be opportunities within the Cypress district,” Councilmember Ray Jackson said.
He floated the idea of container homes on top of existing buildings. He said a container home builder told him the cost could be as low as $60,000 to $80,000. “It’s a lot cheaper to put a container home on top of a building than it is to try to build something from scratch,” he said.
Reiner questioned candidates about the City relinquishing ownership of the beach, Horne weighed the options.
“If the county demands $3 million for lifeguard services for our beach and $1.5 million for beach maintenance services, I believe that we will have to seriously look at whether we can afford to still own our own beach,” Horne said.
“That said, I still want to keep our beach,” he said.
“Hermosa has always owned its own beach. It makes us unique,” Saemann said. He suggested the city sell its surplus sand to neighboring cities for more revenue. “Every time you sell something, you’ll never get it back again,” he said of the beach.
“We own the beach, we control the beach,” Jackson said, adding that the current Presidential administration wants to consider off-shore drilling. He said he has spoken with the county supervisor and expects the county to share costs.
“We’re going to keep our beach. We’re going to keep it. We’re going to own it,” Francois said. “To think that we can transfer ownership and suddenly save all this money is mind boggling.”
“The reason why we’re able to have volleyball tournaments, concerts on the beach, viewing parties for the World Cup soccer is because we own our own beach,” Worner said.
“The beach is both a commercial as well as a cultural icon for us,” Bove-LaMonica said. She said the county’s lifeguard tower at the base of the pier gives the city room to negotiate.
Short-term rentals drew the debate’s sharpest exchanges. Saemann said current rules are “sufficient for the moment.”
“You can evict somebody for any number of reasons, and converting a unit to a short term rental should be just one of them,” he said.
Horne, Bove-LaMonica and Jackson called for caps on the number of short term rentals and their density limits. They also advocated immediate council hearings on the subject. Francois and Worner said the city needs to gather data before holding the hearings.
Five of the six candidates said they support Measure HB, the half-cent sales tax on the November 3 ballot. Francois said he is the only council member who opposes it. ER
Read this story on easyreadernews.com