Hermosa Beach holiday parking program gets a second look
By Laura Garber
by Laura Garber
The free holiday parking program in downtown Hermosa Beach may get a second chance.
Business owners packed Tuesday night’s council meeting to protest the council’s decision at its October 13 meeting to eliminate the program this holiday season. In recent years, the city has bagged downtown meters during the weeks preceding Christmas and through New Year’s Eve.
Councilmember Rob Saemann, who voted with the majority to end the program, said he had changed his mind. The council agreed to bring the program back for a vote, possibly as soon as its next meeting.
Hermosa Beach Chamber of Commerce President Michelle Crispin said businesses were disappointed in the holiday free parking decision.
“We are asking council to reconsider and approve at least two weeks of free holiday parking this year, and to establish a budget line item so that the program can continue for future years,” Crispin said.
Crispin said the Chamber does not have the data requested by the council about how much the free holiday parking increases retail sales.
“Sales taxes are reported quarterly so we can’t isolate December sales or put an exact dollar amount on the impact of free parking,” Crispin said.
Lori Ford co-owns Gum Tree on Pier Ave. with her husband. She said the store has asked for the program every year for 18 years.
“We do 25% of our sales in the month of December,” Ford said.
Ford said a social media post she made about the decision was viewed more than 240,000 times and shared about 3,000 times.
“This is your data,” Ford said. “It’s the opposite of business friendly to make us do this every year.”
Gina Rothwell has owned Sol Baby on Pier Avenue for 20 years.
“We can’t be the only one of the three beach cities that does not offer any type of free holiday parking, especially with Hermosa being the smallest and the one that has the least amount of retail,” Rothwell said.
April Donelson, a representative of Sand Spa, spoke on behalf of owners Megan Richardson-Tiernan and Gretchen Tiernan.
“Going from three weeks last year to zero days this year takes away one of the few tools small businesses have to compete during the most important time of the year,” she said.
Ludmilla Kerr, co-owner of Fritto Misto said the restaurant has been open 27 years.
“This is the hardest year yet that we have,” she said. “We’re doing the best we can, cutting labor, cutting costs, cutting everything.”
Uncorked co-owner Kathy Knoll said this decision was “really bad PR” for the city.
“I’m going to ask for three weeks at least,” Knoll said. “Let’s keep the holiday spirit. No more bah humbug.”
Two council candidates on the November 3 ballot also spoke.
Elka Worner said residents she met while knocking on doors are angry about the decision. She said Manhattan Beach offers free parking from Thanksgiving through Christmas and Redondo Beach offers a week.
“If we’re serious about being a business friendly city, let’s act like one,” Worner said.
Eric Horne tied the decision to Measure HB, the city’s proposed half-cent sales tax. He said some comments on Ford’s post asked why voters should trust the city with a tax increase.
“We are literally voting to cancel Christmas in Hermosa Beach so that we can pay for more coal,” Horne said, referring to the council’s Clean Power Alliance discussion that night.
Horne suggested cutting the city’s public information consultant contract to pay for the program.
Jani Lang, who runs a sales agency serving specialty retailers, proposed free parking on Fridays, Saturdays and Sundays from Thanksgiving to Christmas. Lang also invited council members to work a shift behind a downtown register on November 8.
“Everybody up there has gone on a police ride along during your election campaign,” Lang said. “So I challenge you to do a retail ride along.”
Resident Alain Jauffert defended the cut. He said he believed eliminating the program was the right call given the city’s finances. He noted that no business owners spoke when the item was heard at the previous meeting.
“If the community’s will is to return the parking, I think it is probably the decision you should follow,” Jauffert said. “However, I think that members of this community should be a lot better about showing up to these meetings more frequently. We get a lot of people showing up when they want something from the city. What we don’t have is a lot of people in here when we have budget meetings, when we have to make difficult decisions like cutting our police budget, like cutting our fire budget, making difficult decisions that are going to save the city money.”
Council could not vote on the holiday parking program because it was not on that meeting’s agenda.
Saemann said he had believed ending the program was the right decision given the city’s finances. But he said conversations with business owners changed his view.
“I’ve been very proud of the fact that I’m willing to change my mind from time to time,” Saemann said. “I think that as a councilman or a commissioner, it’s an asset to be able to change your mind.”
Saemann proposed two weeks of free parking, from December 11 through December 25.
Councilmember Dean Francois said he had supported four weeks, but would propose three.
“I’ve supported four weeks of parking. I thought we had a compromise to three. I will propose three weeks,” Francois said.
Near midnight, Saemann asked that the program return for a vote at the next meeting. The proposal received the necessary support to move forward, securing votes from Councilmember Ray Jackson alongside Francois and Saemann. ER
Read this story on easyreadernews.com