Hermosa City Council pulls the plug on holiday parking program
By Laura Garber
by Laura Garber
Hermosa Beach Mayor Mike Detoy saw the backlash coming before he cast the deciding vote.
“I can already see my AI posters all over town as the Grinch,” Detoy said.
The City Council voted 3-2 on Tuesday to suspend the city’s complimentary holiday parking program for 2026. Detoy, Councilmembers Michael Keegan and Rob Saemann voted in favor. Councilmembers Ray Jackson and Dean Francois voted against.
The program has offered free parking at the city’s 388 silver post meters during the holiday shopping season for decades. Last year it ran three weeks, from Dec. 3 through Christmas.
Senior Management Analyst Ken Bales estimated that a three-week program would cost the city about $200,000 in lost meter and citation revenue. Four weeks would cost close to $270,000.
“There is limited evidence demonstrating that the resulting economic activity offsets the city’s subsidy,” Bales said.
Before the vote, several residents said the council has debated the same question for years without data to settle it. Last year the council asked the Chamber of Commerce to provide foot-traffic data from the analytics firm Placer.ai.
“It’s like watching Bill Murray’s Groundhog Day over and over again,” resident Matt McCool said. “Where’s the data? Where’s the data?”
McCool said he doubts the program pays for itself and recommended following Redondo Beach, which offers one week of free parking.
The council then worked through four motions before reaching a decision. Keegan moved for one week. Saemann proposed three weeks, from Dec. 4 to Dec. 25.
“One is too little and four is too much,” Saemann said.
Francois pushed for four weeks, matching Manhattan Beach’s program. He argued staff’s figures reflected gross parking enforcement revenue rather than net revenue after credit card fees, vendor fees and enforcement costs.
Resident Tony Higgins accused Francois of relying on outdated numbers.
“You had a councilman trying to dismiss the hard data from 2025 on the parking ticket revenue and pointing back to 2024, where the rates hadn’t been adjusted,” Higgins said. “It’s misleading and it needs to be addressed.”
“It’s a small price to pay to be in good holiday spirit and allow the businesses to have better competition with our neighboring cities and especially the malls,” Francois said.
Jackson moved for two weeks, with the Chamber of Commerce choosing the dates.
“We have no money, and we’re going to give it away,” Jackson said. “Believe me, I’d love to give parking away for four weeks, but we can’t afford it.”
Keegan supported the two-week motion. He said the city cut the program to two weeks in 2009 during the last financial crisis.
“We have a structural deficit facing us,” Keegan said. “We need to start cutting items where we can.”
He warned residents to expect more of the same.
“There’s going to be a lot of disappointment in the community over the next two years based on our budgeting,” Keegan said. “So get ready for it.”
The two-week motion failed 2-3. Detoy then made the case for no free parking.
“I think the cleanest way to get data is not to do it one year and to do four weeks the next year,” Detoy said. “I was and I still am adamant that we actually don’t do the complimentary holiday parking program this year at all. $200,000 is real public safety costs, real road repaving costs.”
Detoy noted the council had already cut more than $4 million from this year’s budget.
The argument changed Saemann’s mind. He withdrew his three-week motion and seconded Detoy’s.
“Your statement that $200,000 is a meaningful amount of money makes sense to me,” Saemann said.
The vote comes three weeks before the November 3 election, when voters will decide on Measure HB, a proposed half-cent sales tax.
After the vote, Detoy returned to his poster prediction.
“I’ll make the AI posters up for the three of us,” Detoy said. ER
Read this story on easyreadernews.com