Hermosa raises parking permit fees, reverses holiday parking
By Laura Garber
by Laura Garber
Hermosa Beach residents will pay $80 for a residential parking permit next year, up from $60, after the City Council voted November 10 to raise nearly every parking permit fee the city sells.
The residential increase passed 4-1, with Councilmember Michael Keegan voting no. The votes came one week after voters rejected Measure HB, the half-cent sales tax meant to help close the city’s structural deficit.
“We’ve got to raise our fees. Full stop,” Councilmember Ray Jackson said. “Contractors, employees, residents, across the board.”
Jackson said a $60 permit works out to about 13 cents a day for a space that could earn $3.50 an hour at a meter.
“We need the money. We can’t continue the giveaways,” Jackson said.
Councilmember Rob Saemann, who has lived in the permit zone for 35 years, said the program was never meant to make money. He still backed the increase.
“I think that raising it a reasonable amount to $80, it makes sense to me,” Saemann said.
Jackson had proposed charging more for each additional permit, up to $120. Mayor Mike Detoy opposed that.
“When you have roommates and multiple couples living in a place, who’s going to decide who’s going to pay the extra amount?” Detoy said.
Keegan, the lone no vote, also objected.
“It’s not always about the money,” Keegan said. “My neighbors would be terribly offended by $100, $120 permits.”
The council also doubled the daily permit to $24 and raised the monthly contractor permit from $42 to $80. Employee permits on Hermosa Avenue rose from $44 to $50 a quarter. Lot C employee permits rose from $38 to $45 a month for daytime and from $75 to $100 for 24 hours. Event permits rose from $10 to $15, with a limit of 15 per event instead of 10.
Detoy voted against the daily, event and employee increases.
“Cost for these employees who are usually hourly, making minimum wage or a little bit more, is not something I’m interested in addressing right now,” Detoy said.
The council voted 5-0 to tie all non-resident permits to license plates so parking officers can check them with plate-reading cameras. Residents’ transferable hang tags were exempted.
Two other changes failed 2-3. One, proposed by Jackson, would have moved employee permits to an employer-managed system. The other, proposed by Saemann, would have let residents get stickers for cars registered out of state.
The city has issued 6,373 residential permits this season, generating $382,000, according to Revenue Services Supervisor Paul Avila.
Resident Nancy Schwappach questioned whether the city can raise the fee for revenue.
“It is my understanding that this fee for the parking permits can only be cost recovery,” Schwappach said.
Resident Alain Jauffret said parking is one of the few resources the city can monetize.
“These permits should cost a lot more money,” he said.
Permit sales for the 2027-28 season begin February 1, 2027.
Free holiday parking returns
Downtown Hermosa Beach will get free holiday parking this year after all. The City Council voted 4-1 to offer free parking December 11 through December 25 at the city’s 388 commercial-zone meters, reversing its October 13 decision to suspend the program. Mayor Mike Detoy cast the lone no vote, holding his previous position.
Councilmember Rob Saemann, who cast the deciding vote in October, made the motion.
“The city has some serious problems with the budget, and $200,000 is a lot of money,” Saemann said. “Since then, I have spoken to many, many, many business owners, and I have come to realize the importance of this program.”
Councilmember Dean Francois wanted four weeks to match neighboring cities. His substitute motion for three weeks died without a second.
“I think two weeks is just not enough,” Francois said.
Redondo Beach offered four weeks of free holiday parking as recently as 2024. It now offers one week in Riviera Village, which its council kept in this year’s budget after two councilmembers sought to eliminate it. Manhattan Beach plans four weeks, from November 25 to December 25, according to Hermosa staff.
Free parking costs about $66,795 a week in lost meter and citation revenue, staff said, or roughly $134,000 for two weeks.
“It’s seeing the red bags on the meters and knowing that the City is giving a little something back to the community for the holidays,” said Michelle Crispin, president and CEO of the Hermosa Beach Chamber of Commerce.
Resident Vince Busam cited studies from other cities that found free holiday parking does not raise business revenue. He said pricing spaces so cars turn over would help businesses more.
“I don’t think this is about money. This is about feelings,” Busam said. “The businesses want to feel that the city and the residents are making a sacrifice for them.”
Busam said he would pitch in his share if asked. He said the request clashed with the message voters sent a week earlier by rejecting Measure HB.
“Hermosa residents are telling City Council to cut the budget, to cut spending and not raise more money,” Busam said. “But here we’re also asking you to raise spending.”
Laura Pena called in to question the studies, citing rain and COVID-19 restrictions during the periods Santa Monica measured.
“None of them establishes whether or not complimentary parking actually influences customer behavior in our city,” Pena said. ER
Read this story on easyreadernews.com