Manhattan Beach will appoint poet laureate
By Mark McDermott
Poetry won an unlikely victory in an unlikely place earlier this month. The Manhattan Beach City Council, despite staff misgivings, voted unanimously to establish a poet laureate position within the city.
The council allotted an $8,000, two-year stipend and another $5,000 for a small budget for the poet to oversee, with an eye toward furthering poetry within the community.
The cost was never the issue. Senior Recreation Supervisor Eric Brinkman told the council that staff had neither the time nor expertise to manage a poet laureate. He noted that what artistic expertise exists among staff tends toward visual arts.
“In conclusion, staff recognizes the value of poetry and the work of our local poetry community, and this recommendation is not intended to diminish either,” Brinkman said. “The primary concern is not the artistic value of the proposed program, but the additional administrative and ongoing staff commitment required to establish and sustain it, particularly given our existing workload and approved work plan priorities.”
His bureaucratic language was met, appropriately enough, with community poetry.
Bob Perkins, a poet, painter, member of the Poetry Circle and Mira Costa Class of ’61 alum, said staff misunderstood what poets do.
“I don’t know much about staffing, and they don’t know much about poetry,” he said. “That’s what they’re telling me.”
He pointed out that under the proposal, the commission picks the poet and the poet plans the program. Staff does neither.
“There’s only 26 Dodgers. There’s a million Dodger fans,” Perkins said. “There’s not a thousand poets in Manhattan Beach. There are thousands of readers in Manhattan Beach. They can use this service. It may cost us some money. We ought to do it.”
The proposed program came out of the Cultural Arts Commission, which asked to explore a poet laureate in 2024 and has carried it on its work plan since. The money would come from the Public Arts Fund, which holds $1.66 million, $653,868 of it unallocated. The funds cannot be spent on general city operations. The poet would serve a two-year term, write at least four poems a year for the city’s permanent collection, read at one city event each year, and run programs for teens, older adults and all ages.
Brinkman said staff had looked for someone else to run it. The county library declined, because any new program would have to serve the whole county. El Segundo, which has had a poet laureate for three years, reported trouble recruiting poets and filling workshops. Staff suggested parking the idea on the 2027 work plan.
Mayor Pro Tem Nina Tarnay asked whether the arts fund could pay a consultant to run the program instead of staff. City Manager Talyn Mirzakhanian said the municipal code allows only about 20 percent of a project’s public art allocation to go to administration, and anything beyond that would come from the general fund. Brinkman said a consultant would not solve the problem.
“It would still present a very challenging position for staff, particularly when it comes to the providing of facilities. All of that has to go through staff. Communications have to go through staff,” he said. “Providing materials, reimbursements, things like that, that has to go through staff. External consultants don’t have access to internal sort of mechanisms, and so staff is always the go-between for those situations.”
Deb Henderson, a member of the senior Poetry Circle group, said the poet laureate would not need a venue. The city already holds Veterans Day, Memorial Day and 9/11 remembrances. At the Hometown Fair, she read a poem she wrote about the fires.
“One of the residents came up to me with tears in their eyes and said, ‘Thank you for recognizing what we’ve been through,'” Henderson said.
Michelle Murphy said she was not a poet, but her husband is.
“I used to come here and yell at you guys all the time, but I haven’t been in a long time,” she said. “Poets are not well paid. I don’t know if you’ve noticed this, but poets tend to be, you know, starving in garrets or doing something else and writing poetry on the side.”
She cited the Pope’s call for an alliance with artists “to safeguard what is human in the face of AI.”
“I think that the staff is saying we’ve never done this before. Well, so try it,” Murphy said. “It’s time to say yes. Let’s do it.”
Mike Jenkins, a longtime resident, alluded to the poetry of public discourse.
“I’ve always thought my public comments here were poetic, but I don’t know that all of you share that view,” he said.
He urged the council to approve the program in concept and tell staff to design one “that requires a lot less staff time than the staff thinks it involves.”
“With all the talk about fiscal irresponsibility in this town, what are we talking about here?” Jenkins said. “Let’s have some fun with this.”
A man who did not give his name said he sensed a “positivity” around the proposal, and suggested a poet wouldn’t require much help from staff.
“I think poets are pretty independent. They don’t need a lot of management,” he said. “Manhattan Beach needs a voice of and for Manhattan Beach. So I hope you feel what we feel.”
Sherry Yard, a 20-year resident, said she had come to the meeting for another reason.
“After listening to these fabulous poets, I had to say, heck yeah!” she said.
The lone dissent came over Zoom, from Heather Kim, who argued that Mira Costa and middle school students could volunteer to read poems at city events. Then she read one of her own:
“The budget is bleeding/ The ledger is red/ So let’s cut the funding for stanzas instead/ Amazingly, for once/ Even the staff said to pass/ But some politicians keep stepping on the gas.”
“I would urge Miss Kim to submit her application to be our poet laureate,” Tarnay said. “That was a very lovely poem to advocate for your position.”
Tarnay said that, notwithstanding Kim’s poetic dissent, both the community and the council clearly wanted to find a way to make the poet laureate program work.
“Just watching the audience and watching my colleagues tonight, it’s clear to see that we’re all on the same page,” she said. “There’s nothing like government to take the wind out of everyone’s sails. So our challenge today is to try to find a solution.”
Councilmember Amy Howorth said she was looking for “a creative way to yes,” floating a stipend for a staff member or hiring a retired Mira Costa English teacher to help administer the program. Along the way she landed on a title, “a poet administrator.”
“What a great title!” she said.
She picked up Murphy’s point about AI.
“Yes, AI can write poetry, sure, but can it really express what’s in our soul? I don’t think so,” Howorth said. “I mean, it depends on your soul, I suppose.”
She also addressed Kim’s concerns about the money.
“It’s coming from the cultural arts budget,” she said. “I don’t think we’re suggesting any kind of consultants, or, you know, half-time, part-time staffer.”
Councilmember Steve Charelian said he saw no general fund dollars in the proposal.
“I don’t typically agree with Michael Jenkins, but I like what he said up front,” he said.
Councilmember David Lesser said he had a motion ready but offered Mayor Joe Franklin the chance to speak first.
“Roses are red, violets are blue. Let’s skedaddle and woohoo!” Franklin said.
“He’s not submitting for the poet laureate,” Tarnay said.
“I am available,” Franklin noted.
Lesser’s motion directed staff “to find a way to move forward with the poet laureate proposal, to be able to name one as presented in the staff report, notwithstanding the challenges.” He acknowledged a small amount of general fund money might be needed for staff oversight. Tarnay seconded. The vote was 5-0.
“It’s not my first slam,” Howorth said. ER
Read this story on easyreadernews.com