“Minotaur” – Two halves doesn’t equal a whole [MOVIE REVIEW]
By Neely Swanson
“Minotaur” by famed Russian director Andrey Zvyagintsev, writing with Simon Lyaschenko, “Minotaur” is France’s submission to this year’s Academy Awards as an international feature. A head scratcher on several levels, this is a Russian language film starring Russian actors, filmed in Latvia, standing in for Russia. The producers are French, the studio was French and Zvyagintsev is now exiled in France. Technically this may be enough under Academy rules to qualify as a French film. At least France’s submission in 2025, “Emilia Perez,” with an international cast, none of whom were French, was directed by a Frenchman, Jacques Audiard. Cynically “Minotaur” is French on one basic level. Zvyagintsev has based his movie on Claude Chabrol’s “The Unfaithful Wife.” Basing, however, is an understatement because beat for beat, this is Chabrol’s film. But more about that later.
Dmitriy Mazurov. Photo courtesy of MK Films.
Gleb has it all: a successful business, a beautiful home set on expansive grounds abutting a river, a gorgeous wife and adoring son. Emotionless, he expresses no joy or pleasure in his bountiful gifts. He and wife Galina resist eye contact, barely talk, small or otherwise, don’t touch and treat their bedroom as a demilitarized zone. His suspicions about her are aroused when she begins asking him for a ride into town for shopping and spa visits. What could she possibly need that she doesn’t already have? Calling in his head of security, he asks him to find out if his wife is having an affair.
Vladimir Friedman (c), the mayor. Photo courtesy of MK Films.
Problems on the home front are only the beginning of his concerns. Russia’s war with Ukraine demands soldiers, soldiers they don’t have. Each village and town is being asked to draft citizens for the army; volunteers have dried up. The mayor of Gleb’s town has called an executive session with its leaders, all major business or factory owners. He has set a quota establishing the number of workers that they each must submit for the draft. Gleb is intensely loyal to his workers and doesn’t know how to face this dilemma. How he does it, as the film progresses, is wildly clever and intensely diabolical. But this is not the main theme of the movie; this is the political overlay, like a translucent curtain illustrating how moral dilemmas are tackled and avoided in modern Russia where corruption rules and he who shrewdly subverts policy and the police wins, usually at the expense of justice and fairness.
Zvyagintsev is most concerned about the domestic problems between Gleb and his quietly hostile wife, Galina. There is no visible affection. Galina is one of Gleb’s possessions and she longs for more, just not from him. She has every creature comfort but is bored with the material comforts he offers. She’d like excitement, and if intimacy is included in the package, then she’s all in. Yes, Gleb discovers, Galina is having an affair. This is a man who rarely, if ever, fails and somehow he must find a way to win.
Dmitriy Mazurov and Iris Lebedeva. Photo courtesy of MK Films.
Knowing that this film was based on “The Unfaithful Wife,” I was Intrigued by how Zvyagintsev and Lyashenko were going to adapt Chabrol’s vision, and watched the original, made in 1969, starring Chabrol’s exquisite wife Stéphane Audran and Michel Bouquet as the adulterous wife Hélène and cuckolded husband Henri. “Minotaur” follows all the plot points, and I mean all the plot points, missing only the emotion. The rift in their relationship, the rift that drives Hélène to find sexual comfort with another man, is a need for passion and intimacy in her marriage. She is not bored, she loves her husband but is seeking something she feels is missing, while trying not to destroy the fabric of her family. “Minotaur” is a beat for beat, scene for scene, duplicate of the original missing only the most important factor, that she cheats not because she’s bored or angry but because she’s seeking the only element missing from her charmed life. The excitement she feels when her husband, and this would be a spoiler so I won’t state it directly, takes action against her lover, is pivotal. It is a major and surprising trigger to the passion that had been otherwise lacking. This is also what is lacking in “Minotaur.” There is no passion in the inevitable reconciliation of the partners. Henri is awakened by his one violent act in defense of his marriage. Gleb, committing the same crime, still seems somnolent. The dialogue may be different in the two films, and I can’t tell because I don’t speak Russian, still, it borders on an act of plagiarism even with the credit to Chabrol as being “based on” his film.
I might have felt differently about “Minotaur” if I hadn’t rewatched the original, but it clouded my appreciation for what might have been a good film about a wealthy, but not oligarch wealthy, Russian family and the corruption of daily life, of which Gleb is an active participant, calling in favors for self protection and gaming the system for his own aims.
The cinematography and production design are first rate, far superior to “The Unfaithful Wife” whose film style, revolutionary at the time, doesn’t hold up. But the storytelling and character interactions are what make the older film resonate in ways “Minotaur” doesn’t.
In Russian with English subtitles.
Opening November 20 at the AMC Century City.
Read this story on easyreadernews.com