Racist hate threats and graffiti roil Mira Costa High School
By Mark McDermott
A Mira Costa High School student allegedly threatened violence against a Black student, and a spate of anti-Black and anti-Jewish graffiti on MBUSD campuses resulted in a standing-room only school board meeting on Nov. 4. Teachers and students testified that the district had too long tolerated a hostile environment, and one mother said she and her family no longer felt safe enough to continue living in Manhattan Beach.
“I don’t feel safe for my daughter,” said Laura Leigh Hughes, the mother of a biracial Mira Costa senior. “I don’t feel like it is a safe environment for people of color.”
Over the course of nearly two hours, more than a dozen speakers addressed the hate incidents at the Nov. 4 meeting of the Manhattan Beach Unified School District Board of Education. Roughly 20 more submitted written comments.
Board President Tina Shivpuri opened the meeting with a statement on behalf of the board. She recalled the “Inclusion Stand Up Commitment,” a joint resolution the district and the city adopted in 2017 after alumni came forward with accounts of hate on and off campus.
“Nearly a decade later, that commitment remains just as important, particularly in light of recent incidents of anti-Black hate and anti-Semitism, and concerns expressed by our students, our families, and members of our community,” Shivpuri said.
Superintendent Kim Linz followed with her own statement.
“In recent weeks, our district has once again received reports and has dealt with incidents of hate speech, intimidation, and hateful threats on our campuses, specifically anti-Black racist threats,” Linz said. “I want to be clear: this is more than a series of isolated incidents. Coupled with the recent anti-Semitism at our schools, it is a call to action for our district and our entire community.”
“Can we do better? Yes, we can, and we will.”— Kim Linz, MBUSD superintendent
The district has released few details. Mira Costa Principal Jennifer Huynh first wrote to families on Friday, Oct. 30. Her email referred to “recent incidents” and said there was no place at the school for “racially-charged language, hate speech, racism, antisemitism, or language intended to demean, threaten, or make others feel unwelcome.” It did not say what had happened, or to whom.
“We ask our community to understand that these limitations are not a lack of transparency,” Huynh wrote, citing student privacy laws.
Three days later, on Monday, Nov. 2, Huynh wrote again.
“We are aware the information we shared last week about reports regarding a student using racist remarks and violent verbal threats was not clear enough,” she wrote. She said the school could not comment on details or discipline because of student privacy and “an ongoing investigation.”
“In general, our policy when there are incidents of hate is to investigate, apply appropriate discipline, report to the police, and institute restorative practices such as education and/or a juvenile diversion program,” Huynh wrote.
Neither email used the word Black. Linz acknowledged the omission at the meeting.
“You’ve told us that our recent communications left you without the context and direct naming of racist violence that was needed,” Linz said. “I understand the frustration, and I hear that when families don’t have information, it is hard to help, and it is easy to assume that nothing is being done.”
According to accounts given by several speakers at the meeting, a Mira Costa student repeatedly threatened a Black classmate, used the N-word, and claimed to be a member of the Ku Klux Klan. Some of the speakers, including a student who said he witnessed an incident, said the threat was to burn the student.
Speakers also said the student who was threatened reported it to a teacher, and nothing was done, and that the student who made the threats was suspended for two days. The district, constrained by privacy laws, has confirmed little about the details of the incident.
“A horrific incident involving anti-Black hate speech, specifically the N-word, and threats of violence toward a student was reported at the high school,” said Maddie Hutchinson, a Mira Costa teacher. “This is completely unacceptable and heartbreaking, especially when we acknowledge that acts of hatred and bias happen all the time in our district. Every single year I’ve taught, which is 13, I have heard students talk about hearing slurs in the hallways, feeling unsafe because of their identity, and fearing coming to school. This is far from a one-off.”
“A vague email is not enough,” Hutchinson said. “We are not saying to break confidentiality laws. We are not suggesting that we directly name perpetrators. However, we can call things what they are. There is a massive difference between saying an act of hate took place and specifying that anti-Black rhetoric and the N-word was used.”
“Tonight is the most direct you’ve been, which I appreciate,” Hutchinson said.
“Get used to it”
London Bomani Laurencio, a Mira Costa student and member of the school’s Black Scholars Union, questioned whether either the student who made the threat or the teacher who witnessed it would be held accountable.
“My peer, he was affected by hate threats on campus, right?” Laurencio said. “He told the teacher. She completely neglected it. Where’s the consequence in that?”
“I don’t think we understand how big of a job teachers have,” he said. “Teachers are literally carving a footprint for us.”
He said the student who made the threat should not be allowed back on campus.
“We haven’t seen him at school, and so we can likely assume that he was suspended, right? And we should be expecting expulsion,” Laurencio said. “To be a student means to come to school to learn. Is he coming to school to learn, or is he coming to school to express his opinions … and hurt another student, and hurt a full body of students? Black students feel uncomfortable, unsafe, unheard, invalidated all over this campus.”
“I don’t think he just learned this and picked it up online,” Laurencio said. “It could have been, but I think that he picked this up from his community, and I think that’s big.”
A Mira Costa senior, Alessia Osterling Tawataban, said the consequences needed to be made clear.
“What is the minimum consequence when a student makes a racially motivated threat to kill another student? Right now, students are hearing that the answer is a short suspension, two days,” she said. “If that’s wrong, tell us what the policy is. If it is right, then the policy is not enough … You do not learn the weight of threatening somebody’s life by spending a few days at home.”
She said what occurred was not an isolated incident.
“As a senior, I will be leaving Mira Costa in a few months, and I cannot leave without speaking up, because this is not the first time students on these grounds have faced racism and anti-Semitism, from slurs yelled during a football game at the opposing team’s Black cheerleaders to swastikas etched into trash cans and bathroom mirrors.”
Janet Allen has worked as a school psychologist in the district for 25 years. In 2010, she and a colleague founded the Black Scholars Union at Mira Costa. She has been its faculty advisor for 16 years. She is also the mother of twin boys who are Mira Costa seniors.
“What our students carry in their backpacks to school every day is more than their books,” Allen told the board. “What is on their mind, in their memory, in their processing, is more than what they studied for classes, for tests. It is hate. It is language. It is threats. It is anxiety for safety. It is fear for safety. It is being told that the N-word is normalized at our school. Get used to it. It is being told that anti-Semitism is normal. Get used to it.”
“Our students do not deserve that type of language exposure in an educational environment,” she said. “They deserve people to stand up for them.”
Allen said her sons encountered anti-Black hate at Manhattan Beach Middle School, and again at Mira Costa.
“Both of my twins go off to college with those years of hate at Mira Costa,” she said. “We need to have preventative measures, not just reactive measures, not just discipline.”
Hughes, the mother who said she no longer felt safe, told the board her family came to Mira Costa after the Palisades fire burned her daughter’s school.
“I cannot say enough good things about how Mira Costa welcomed us. I will be forever grateful,” she said. “[But] I have never experienced the racism like we have here.”
The family eventually moved to Redondo Beach. She described two nights out in Riviera Village. On one, she said, a group of white middle school boys on e-bikes yelled the N-word at a passing car, and then at her and her daughter after she confronted them. On another, she said, a white woman looked into their car and said, “Why don’t you go back to Compton?”
“My daughter said to me, ‘Mom, you’re more upset about this than I am,’” Hughes said. “I really wonder how that lands with her. As a mom, I just don’t know how I can protect my child.”
“I thought I might stay in this area, and I will not now,” she said. “We will be moving back to our home in LA.”
“Our children are suffering, and when any children suffer, all children suffer,” Hughes said. “I hope the consequences match the severity of these actions. I don’t think they have.”
Alicia Fall, the mother of a Mira Costa student, read from a letter written by another Black mother, who was not named.
“My daughter, like many Black students attending predominantly white schools, regularly experiences microaggressions,” the letter said. “Throughout her time at Mira Costa, she’s witnessed and endured an environment in which racial slurs are overheard, offensive racial jokes are exchanged, and racist graffiti appears on school property.”
“These are not isolated incidents,” the letter said. “Collectively, they create an environment where Black students must constantly negotiate their sense of belonging, dignity, and personal safety.”
Fall then spoke for herself.
“I just thought it was important that you hear another Black mother,” she said. “A lot of Black parents are tired. We carry so much weight from work, from the regular, in addition to racism, and it’s hard, and we want change.”
Allison Hales, founder of the nonprofit Culture Club South Bay, said she has been speaking out since the city’s Bruce’s Beach Task Force.
“Do you truly understand how tiring and disappointing it is to keep having to show up in this town for my fellow Black people who are attacked and abused in your school systems, in our community?” Hales said. “This has been going on for me personally for seven years, and I’m sick and tired of it.”
Several teachers likewise described a racially fraught environment at MBUSD campuses.
Diana Sieker has taught English in the district for 21 years. She lives in Hawthorne. She said she has heard Mira Costa students call neighboring cities “ghetto.”
“No one in my neighborhood makes sick and twisted jokes about slavery or lynching,” Sieker said. “No one in my neighborhood purports to be a member of the KKK to terrorize others, and never have I ever seen any form of anti-Semitic graffiti or swastikas in my neighborhood. But these are all things that I’ve seen repeatedly here within the Manhattan Beach Unified School District.”
“Beyond the polished newsletters, the glossy photo shoots, the social media campaigns, who are we?” she said.
Mira Costa teacher Dan Cashman spoke directly to Shivpuri’s and Linz’s statements.
“We have heard all of those words that you gave before, and at this point, those words ring hollow because we have not seen action,” Cashman said. “It is heartbreaking to hear kids say, ‘I’m not going to report it because I don’t know what that means. I’ve been told by my family to just keep my head down and shut up and just deal with it because that’s the best we’ve got. You’re lucky to get to go to Costa.’ That’s not acceptable.”
“We have a stand-up commitment. Great. We have a culture of care. Great,” he said. “Where is the action that goes along with all of those words?”
“This is not new”
The experiences described at the board meeting recall several incidents that have occurred locally over the past decade and more.
In February 2015, a burning tire was set against the front door of the Manhattan Beach home of Ronald and Malissia Clinton, a Black family. Hundreds of residents attended a vigil at Metlox Plaza days later.
In June 2021, a swastika was drawn on a sidewalk at Mira Costa, MB News reported.
In 2022, swastikas appeared repeatedly at Mira Costa, beginning in late January, and on playground equipment at Robinson Elementary. In July, antisemitic and racist graffiti was painted across the Meadows Elementary playground. In September, swastikas and the words “Gas the Jews” were written across the Mira Costa campus. More than two hours of public testimony followed at the Sept. 14, 2022 school board meeting, and the board approved $383,000 for security cameras at Mira Costa and MBMS. Days later, hateful phrases and swastikas were found at Pennekamp Elementary. It was the ninth such report on district campuses that year.
On Sept. 30, 2022, during a football game at Mira Costa’s Waller Stadium, a group of Manhattan Beach Middle School students “used the ‘N-word’ and threw items at our visiting guests from Culver City,” then-Superintendent John Bowes wrote to families.
That November, MBUSD became the first school district in Los Angeles County to earn the Anti-Defamation League’s “No Place for Hate” designation.
On Nov. 1, 2023, weeks after the Hamas attacks on Israel, more than 70 parents came to a school board meeting to protest the district’s handling of a report that an MBMS student had verbally harassed four Jewish girls. The board read a statement apologizing for how it initially handled the complaint.
On Feb. 8, 2024, the N-word was found written on a wall near Mustang Mall at Mira Costa. It was Black History Month, and the day of the Black Scholars Union’s 11th annual assembly. Bowes called it a hate crime.
This spring, swastikas were found in a boys’ restroom stall at Mira Costa on April 30, and again in the same stall on May 8. The district later told parents it had identified and disciplined a student.
And in recent weeks, a swastika and other hate speech were found in a boys’ bathroom at MBMS, according to several accounts.
“This is not new,” wrote parent Kenia Khavari, in a comment submitted to the board that listed several of the incidents. “Different targets. The same pattern: a statement, a cleanup, and then the next incident.”
“This district earned a ‘No Place for Hate’ designation,” Khavari wrote. “That is a promise to every child here, whatever their faith or race. A promise is kept by what happens after the statement.”
Lana Rizika wrote that her daughter graduated from MBMS in 2013 “and complained of antisemitism back then, 13 years ago. And we are still here.”
Two written comments described a second case. Laura Kiely and Desiree Brown, a member of MB United, wrote that the family of a former Black Mira Costa student had posted publicly that their son received death threats last year from a student who claimed to be in the KKK, and that the family was asked by a district official to keep quiet.
“Silence is not protection,” Brown wrote. “A forced apology is not accountability. And waiting until tragedy strikes is not an option.”
Michael Jenkins, a 48-year resident and a member of MB United, reached further back.
“I was pretty shocked to hear that we had a student who, at least according to social media accounts, claimed to be a member of the KKK,” Jenkins said. “Back in the 1920s, we had the KKK here, and they influenced the city council to take land from the Bruce family and other Black families down at Bruce’s Beach. So it’s pretty shocking for me to hear that we still have people here who proudly say that they are members of the KKK.”
“I know you care, so I’m not here to yell at you tonight,” he told the board. “I just think it’s pretty apparent that something’s not working.”
Speakers asked for specific things.
Diana Skaar, a Mira Costa parent who helped implement No Place for Hate at MBMS, asked the district to publish a dashboard reporting the number and types of incidents and how they are addressed. She also explained why the wording of the principal’s emails mattered.
“For me, there’s a difference in denouncing all forms of hate, akin to saying that all lives matter, versus naming, say, anti-Asian hate,” she said. “As an Asian American, I know what the latter means. It tells me that you see me.”
“Ultimately, we are here tonight because there’s a lack of trust in whether all staff across the district are equipped to meet the moment and do the right thing,” Skaar said. “We can’t have a student report an incident to a trusted adult only to have them feel like they just got brushed off.”
Julie Burkle, a 30-year resident, asked the district to keep the student who was threatened away from the student who threatened him.
“There’s laws against a hostile work environment, and these children are facing a hostile educational environment,” Burkle said.
Linz told the audience what the district intends to do. She said it is meeting with students, training staff “with student voices” on recognizing and responding to hate, scheduling assemblies and lessons, and holding student-led discussions at Mira Costa. She said it is reviewing its own practices.
“I have also heard a clear message from students and families that when students don’t see that reports lead to action, they stop reporting,” Linz said. “That concerns me.”
“Can we do better? Yes, we can, and we will,” she said.
In a letter to families on Monday, Nov. 9, Linz said the district is “re-establishing a District-level Superintendent’s Advisory Committee” that “will include significant student presence,” and is conducting regular campus sweeps for graffiti.
“We will do the work, but we cannot do it alone,” Linz wrote. “We need our families and community as partners.”
Huynh’s Nov. 2 email said Mira Costa staff would receive mandatory training with “actionable steps”: listen attentively to student reports, document the facts, address immediate classroom needs, and escalate to an administrator. It said administrators would visit “the classroom where incidents occurred.”
Laurencio, the Black Scholars Union member, ended his remarks to the board with a request.
“I just think that we were very affected by this,” he said, “and I would like some change, please.” ER
Editor’s note: Dr. Kim Linz’s most recent statement regarding the incident at Mira Costa:
“We understand and share the deep concern and frustration expressed by our school community. Racist threats, hate speech, and intimidation have absolutely no place in MBUSD. Every student deserves to feel safe, respected, and supported at school.
“When incidents are reported, we are responsible for conducting a thorough investigation, supporting those affected, notifying law enforcement, and taking disciplinary action consistent with District policies and the school disciplinary matrix. We have taken these steps in this case.
“We recognize the need for clear, consistent communication while also protecting student privacy, which limits the details we can share, particularly during active investigations. We are reviewing our reporting and response practices to strengthen both consistency and transparency.
“We are also taking additional steps to strengthen our Districtwide response through staff training, student-led conversations, and the formation of a Superintendent’s Advisory Committee with significant student representation. We will continue to provide counseling and administrative support to students and staff affected by these incidents. This work is essential to ensuring every student feels safe, valued, and a sense of belonging in our schools.”
Kim Linz
Superintendent, Manhattan Beach Unified School District
Read this story on easyreadernews.com