16 sick following former RPV mayor’s birthday party at Trump National [Updated Mar. 23, 2020]
Two days before Susan Brooks’ 70th birthday party at Trump National Golf Club Los Angeles in Rancho Palos Verdes, she sent a cautionary Evite.com message to the 65 invited guests.
“I told them that in light of the global virus situation, please stay home if you are not feeling well and if you do come, practice social distancing. No kissing. No hugging,” Brooks said in a phone interview on Sunday, two Sundays after the March 8 party.
Fourth District Supervisor Janice Hahn and Rancho Palos Verdes Mayor John Cruikshank were among the many, locally prominent political guests. Brooks served on the Rancho Palos Verdes City Council from 1991 to 1995 and again from 2011 to 2019. She ran unsuccessfully for Congress as the Republican Party candidate in 1994, 1996 and 1998.
The Sunday following her party, on the day Governor Gavin Newsom directed Californians over 65 to self isolate, Brooks sent a second, more alarming Evite.com message to her birthday party guests. A man who had attended her birthday party, she wrote, had called that day to tell her he and his wife had tested positive for the coronavirus.
Over the following week, 15 of her guests reported falling ill. Brooks subsequently tested positive and two of the male guests were hospitalized and placed on ventilators.
“They were both healthy, older men. It seems more of the men got sick than women. And there were couples who attended and only one got sick,” Brooks said.
It is not known how many of the other ill guests contracted the coronavirus because not all have been able to get tested.
Superintendent Hahn, on the day following Brooks’ message about the couple who had tested positive, announced she was going into self-isolation at her home in San Pedro.
“The supervisor has not been tested, but she shows no symptoms of the coronavirus and it has been two weeks since she attended the birthday party,” Hahn’s director of communications Liz Odendahld said Monday. Hahn wrote in a March 19 column for Easy Reader that she self-isolated because she is over 65. “I am following the Governor’s orders and it is important that you do, too,” she wrote.
Rancho Palos Verdes Mayor John Cruikshank did test positive for the coronavirus, creating a domino effect at City Hall. Because of their contact with the mayor following the party, City Manager Ara Mihranian and Interim Deputy City Manager Kit Fox, like Cruikshank, went into home isolation and city hall underwent a deep cleaning.
The usually upbeat Brooks used an unprintable word to describe how the illness made her feel. She said it was “the worst flu ever” and that she is struggling to keep her lungs from becoming infected because she has asthma.
“I was on FaceTime with my grandchildren today,” Brooks said. “They were showing me their Legos and stuffed animals and I felt like I was going to faint. I told them, ‘Grandma has to go lie down.’”
Brooks agreed to talk about her birthday party, she said, because she wants people to know how easily the virus spreads.
The guest who called Brooks to warn he and his wife had tested positive was Dr. Edward Piken, a local gastroenterologist. Three days after the birthday party, Piken and his wife Kelly dined at the Palos Verdes Country Club. The next morning, they tested positive for the virus, prompting the club to close until at least March 31. In a letter to members, the club noted the Pikens had recently returned from a cruise, leading to suspicion that the couple was the source of contagion at the Trump National birthday party.
But in an interview Monday, Piken said he believes he and his wife contracted the virus at the birthday party, not on the cruise ship. No one else on the cruise has contracted the virus and none of the 70 guests he had at his home two days before the birthday party have contracted the virus, he said. The party at his home was a memorial service for his father, who passed away that week at age 111. The Pikens also attended a party of 40 people the afternoon of Brooks’ birthday party and none of those guests have reported being sick, Piken said.
Brooks agreed it is not possible to know who might have brought the virus to her party. She said a second guest exhibited coronavirus symptoms the day after her party, suggesting the guest would have been infectious at the party even without exhibiting symptoms.
Though the party was before “social distancing” was common parlance, before schools and businesses were closed and on the same day 20,000 people ran in the Los Angeles Marathon, Brooks said she encouraged guests to greet one another with toe taps.
“Some of the guests practiced social distancing, but others didn’t take it seriously,” Brooks said.
The ‘70s, disco-themed birthday party included a DJ, disco ball and dancing, but did not include a sit-down dinner. Servers passed hors d’oeuvres trays of lollipop lamb, coconut shrimp, ahi wontons and beef chimichurri. The bar served wines from the Boisset Wine Club.
“Maybe the virus was passed around by the hors d’oeuvres tray,” Brooks said. “We don’t really know. My doctor said my party shows how easily the virus spreads and how important it is to avoid groups.”
“There were people mad at me because I didn’t invite them,” she said. “But they’re not mad at me now.” ER
Be an Easy Reader Free Press supporter!
Yes, we know Easy Reader and EasyReaderNews.com are free. But they are not free to produce. The advertiser model that traditionally supported newspapers is fading away. This is our way of transitioning to a future where newspapers are supported by their readers. Which is as it should be. We hope you’ll support us. — Kevin Cody, Publisher